The most common mistakes San Jose owners make with a merchant cash advance happen before they ever talk to an MCA defense lawyer, and they usually come down to letting a court deadline slide or making moves (stacking a new advance, agreeing to new terms on the phone) that make the case harder to defend. If a funder is threatening to sue or already has a judgment, the first few days matter more than most people expect.

None of this is legal advice, and a lot of it depends on what your specific contract says, so treat it as a checklist to bring to counsel in Santa Clara County.

Why do owners sit on MCA court papers until it's too late?

A lot of owners get a demand letter, panic, and then freeze because the letter reads like the end of the road. Demand letters are mostly pressure. Papers from a court are a different animal, since a summons or a notice of entry of judgment comes with a deadline, and missing it can hand the funder a win without anyone asking whether the contract was fair.

Out-of-state judgments are where San Jose businesses get caught most often. Many MCA contracts send disputes to another state's courts, so a funder may get a judgment there and then bring it to California. The state handles that under its own Sister State Money Judgments Act, and once you're served with the notice of entry of judgment, you have 30 days to move to vacate it on any ground that would be a defense to a suit on the judgment (Code of Civil Procedure 1710.40).

Enforcement usually can't start until 30 days after that notice is served, but a creditor can move sooner against out-of-state debtors and out-of-state companies not qualified to do business in California (section 1710.45). If your company was formed in another state but operates in San Jose, ask a lawyer about this right away.

Does a confession of judgment still count against a California business?

Owners tend to make one of two opposite mistakes here: some assume a signed confession of judgment means the funder can drain the account tomorrow and agree to whatever is offered, while others hear that confessions are banned and stop reading anything the funder sends.

California's rule is fairly clear. Since January 1, 2023, a judgment by confession is unenforceable and can't be entered in any California superior court, including the one in Santa Clara County (Code of Civil Procedure 1132). Confessions obtained or entered before that date are not affected, so the dates on your paperwork matter. New York closed a related door in August 2019, when it amended CPLR 3218 so a confession can only be filed in the county where the defendant lived or was based when it signed, which means an out-of-state merchant's confession can no longer be filed there.

The catch is that losing the confession shortcut doesn't erase the debt. A funder can still sue on the contract itself, and California allows four years to bring an action on a written contract (Code of Civil Procedure 337), so a lawyer will want to know when you signed and whether anything has been filed. AB 2116 will bar providers from taking a confession of judgment or power of attorney before default, but most of it isn't operative until January 1, 2028, so it's unlikely to change a dispute you're in now.

Is it a mistake to stop the ACH debits or switch banks?

This one is tempting, especially when the daily debit is what's bouncing your rent check. Revoking the ACH authorization or moving to a new bank can stop the bleeding for a week, but done on your own it usually trips the default clause, and since many MCAs include a personal guaranty, the funder's next move may be aimed at you as well as the business.

Funders also typically file a UCC-1 financing statement on business assets and receivables, which gives them a lien and more leverage than an ordinary unsecured creditor once things go sideways. If your agreement has a reconciliation clause, asking in writing for the payment to be adjusted to your actual revenue is usually a safer first step than cutting off the debits, and how the funder responds can matter later.

That response can also feed a bigger argument a lawyer may raise, which is whether your MCA was really a loan. Funders structure these deals as purchases of future receivables so state usury caps don't apply, and courts look at the substance, such as whether the reconciliation clause was real and whether you'd still owe if the business failed in good faith.

Why does taking a second advance make things worse?

Stacking is how a rough month turns into a lawsuit. The new funder's debit lands on top of the old one, and the cash that was supposed to fix the problem is usually gone within weeks.

Take an example with made-up numbers. Say you took $40,000 at a 1.4 factor rate, so you owe $56,000. Two months later you take $30,000 from a second funder at a 1.45 factor rate, so that one is $43,500. You now owe a combined $99,500 on $70,000 of cash with both funders collecting at the same time, and many contracts treat taking additional financing as a default on its own, so check yours.

Stacking also makes the defense messier, since multiple funders may hold liens on the same receivables. If you're already stacked, hold off on adding another position, and bring every agreement to the lawyer, including ones you think are paid off.

What goes wrong when you negotiate with a funder on the phone?

Collections calls from MCA funders can be aggressive, and plenty of owners agree to things just to end the call. A verbal promise to pay a set amount by Friday, or an offhand admission that the business “just stopped paying,” can show up later in a complaint.

The bigger risk is the “modification” or “forbearance” agreement that lands in your inbox the next morning. These sometimes add a fresh personal guaranty or ask you to waive defenses you didn't know you had. California's SB 666 voids waivers of the protections in that law, but a new agreement can still hurt you in other ways, so don't sign anything until someone working for you has read it.

Which records should you keep before talking to a lawyer?

Throwing out the offer paperwork quietly costs owners real arguments. California's Commercial Financing Disclosure Law (SB 1235) requires disclosures on commercial financing offers of $500,000 or less, and the state regulator, DFPI, says that includes merchant cash advances. Since December 9, 2022, the required disclosures have included the funding amount, an APR, the payment amount and the term, and the provider isn't supposed to finalize the deal until you've signed them. Some providers are exempt, so let a lawyer look at what you actually got.

Fees matter too. SB 666, in effect since January 1, 2024, bars providers from charging small businesses certain fees on financing of $500,000 or less, including charges for processing ACH debits (insufficient-funds fees aside) and add-ons with no clear service behind them, like “due diligence” or “platform” fees. A covered business can sue for actual damages, statutory damages of $500 to $2,500, and attorney's fees and costs. Coverage is limited to businesses with a principal office in California, 100 or fewer employees and average annual gross receipts of $15 million or less, so check whether yours fits.

Keep the signed contract, every disclosure, bank statements showing each debit, and any letters or court papers in one folder. If you were misled or never got proper disclosures, DFPI has asked small businesses to report it, and you can do that through its complaint page.

How do you find and vet an MCA defense lawyer in San Jose?

The mistake at this stage is hiring whoever bought the top search ad, or assuming any business lawyer handles MCA cases well. A good place to start is the State Bar of California's certified lawyer referral services, where you can ask specifically for someone who has defended funder lawsuits and sister-state judgment filings. When you get someone on the phone, these questions help separate real experience from a sales pitch:

  • How many MCA lawsuits or out-of-state judgment challenges have you handled recently?
  • Have you raised recharacterization or usury arguments against a funder, and how did the court respond?
  • Do you bill hourly or a flat fee per stage, and what's a realistic budget through an answer or a motion to vacate?
  • Who on your team actually does the work, and how fast do you respond near a deadline?
  • Are you comfortable coordinating with a settlement company if the business is negotiating with other funders at the same time?

The California MCA defense lawyers guide covers statewide rules in more depth, and owners with locations up the peninsula may also want the San Francisco MCA defense page.

Where does a settlement company fit next to your lawyer?

Another mistake is assuming a settlement company can handle a lawsuit, when only licensed counsel can file an answer or move to vacate a domesticated judgment. Settlement firms negotiate balances and payment terms, which is a separate job.

When several funders are involved, a firm that negotiates MCA balances directly, such as Delancey Street, can work on the funders who haven't sued and on turning daily debits into payments the business can carry, while your lawyer handles whatever is already in court. Settlement is never guaranteed, and funders can still sue while you're in a program. Money sitting in a savings or escrow account isn't a payment to the funder either, so keep your lawyer informed about every deal on the table.

Whoever negotiates the final number, get the terms in writing, including the funder's obligation to file a UCC-3 termination releasing its UCC-1 lien once the settlement is paid, because a lien that never gets released can follow the business into its next financing application.